Card Sorting
Home
There were four main similarities spread across the menu systems and those were ‘Current events at the café’, ‘A linked to the donation site’, ‘Social media links’ and ‘Promotions’. Current events at the café will be very important to include on the homepage because there are always new things going on. These can range from evening workshops to art exhibitions in the area. During my second meeting with Tigger, it came to light that he really wants to emphasise the feeling of community in the café. The events that he holds are a perfect way to achieve this and by displaying them at the forefront of the website, The Greenhouse Trust may be able to attract new clientele as User 2 to suggested in reply to my survey. This can also fall hand-in-hand with including promotions and draw new customers in. Additionally, as a charity organisation they naturally rely heavily on donations, therefore a link to the donation site and a brief description of why you should donate should be included to boost recognition and ease-of-use. The last main similarity was the incorporation of social media links on the homepage. It is not uncommon for businesses to have this on their homepage to increase their presence over multiple social platforms, however, Robin did raise an interesting idea of which to attach social media links to a static bar that is visible from every page. I like this idea because it will encourage networking and if I was to also include a donation button then users may be psychologically more inclined to give money if they are faced with this option at the top of each page every time it refreshes.
About (and The Greenhouse)
After performing this prototype test and being able to analyse the way users have grouped content, I have come to realise I may have been looking at these two sections in the wrong way. Instead of having separate headers where the About section includes ‘Find Us’ and ‘Contact Us’ and The Greenhouse section includes content such as ‘Environmental features of The Greenhouse’ and ‘History of The Greenhouse’, the About section can inherit all the information regarding The Greenhouse. Thus, removing ‘The Greenhouse’ from the main menu options and instead potentially creating a call to action for this information in a parallax section on the homepage.
Café & Shop
The Café and Shop section was always going to be rather self-explanatory, and the results mainly confirm my previous assumptions. Information such as the café menu and opening times were always going to fall into this category, however, I am looking to duplicate content here that can also be found in the ‘About’ section. At this point, I am only looking to duplicate the Google Maps API so users know how to find the café along with contact details as it would be convenient for this information to also be displayed here. In addition to this, I will be adding the events section of the website into this category because technically these to take place in the café area. I will assign it a call-to-action on the homepage which will direct the user here.
I will be keeping the Café and Shop title as the majority of my testers and myself agree this grouping makes logical sense. Only one participant of my test suggested I separate these, resulting in one section for Café in one section for Shop. I am hesitant to split them as that would result in eight options for the user to choose from in the main menu bar and this completely contradicts my original hypothesis. This refers back to Hick’s Law which states that if a participant is presented with too many stimuli, they will get distracted easily, struggle to choose an option and may end up abandoning the task altogether. Interestingly, however, this same participant suggested that I fuse together ‘Volunteer’ and ‘Donate’. I can see how these two may fall into the same category as well, however seeing as it is between the two, I will keep both as is.
Art & Literature
Two users suggested a separate header for Art and Literature/Writing. I had not previously considered something like this, so for my hybrid card sorting exercise to produce this kind of result proved to me how worthwhile the nature of the experiment really is. I instantly saw how this could be a fantastic idea with a lot of beneficial qualities. Firstly, this solves the issue of overcrowding of content in the Café and Shop section. This was a previous concern of mine as previously ‘Shop’ was covered the food store, wine store, bookstore and artwork for sale. Now, I can amalgamate the creative aspects of the charity all in one section. In the second-tier menu, I plan to have one option for ‘Art’ and one option for ‘Literature’. The ‘Art’ section includes a small digital art gallery, similar to the one that appears on the website now and information about the artists. Users will also be able to find information about current art exhibition on in the area that the charity is contributing to. This information will also be able to be found in the generalised ‘Events’ section, by placing it here as well I hope to boost recognition of artists work. The ‘Literature’ section will be considerably smaller and include some short pieces by local writers. When the development of the site becomes more advanced I will be looking into whether any other content can be added here.
Volunteer
The volunteer section was very similar across the board and included ‘How to volunteer’ and ‘About volunteering’. As the volunteer section is considerably smaller than the rest, all the information should be able to fit on one page. It will start with a brief introduction to what it is like to volunteer for The Greenhouse Trust and then go into more details about the roles and responsibilities there are available. At the bottom of the page will be a downloadable application form so users are able to print it off and fill it in prior to visiting the café to hand it in. At this point, I do not plan to have any second tier menu options however I will see how the website comes along in the main build.
Donate
Tree Testing
Ameer (decided to do the volunteer information task first)
1. Home
2. Volunteer
3. Home
4. About
5. Find Us
6. About
7. Home
8. Welcome to the Greenhouse
Additional comments: The text in the “Welcome to the Greenhouse” section, information regarding the history of The Greenhouse and the local area and ‘Meet Us’ should all be featured in the ‘About’ section. The ‘Meet Us’ could also be used as a friendly introduction on the homepage as well.
Kieran
1. Home
2. Volunteer
3. Find Us
4. *Clicks onto Google Maps and tries to find directions on there*
5. The Greenhouse
6. Meet Us
7. Environmental Features
Additional comments: Each of the actions dictated by the user story was easily available on the main menu bar. When I wanted to find out where the Forum car park is there is no ‘directions’ option. The API used at the moment is OK for people who live close but if you are travelling from outside Norwich this can become an issue. All in all, the look and feel of the site is enjoyable so far.
Jason
1. Home
2. *Scrolls down and up home page*
3. Meet Us
4. Welcome to The Greenhouse
5. Find Us
6. Volunteer
Additional comments: There should be more information on the homepage e.g. Find us, about us, volunteer. These would include click-through links to the pages on the site. The small and lightly coloured text would be difficult for users like Deborah who have weakened eyesight to read. The volunteer page could include more specific content such as roles.
George
1. Home
2. Welcome to The Greenhouse
3. Food Information
4. Wine Information
5. Volunteer
6. Home
7. Find Us
8. Volunteer
9. Art Gallery
10. Book Shop
11. Gift Aid Form.pdf
Additional comments: It was easy to find a page, but when I clicked on the Welcome to The Greenhouse page I didn’t realise that was the page I was already on. I felt like it was laid out sensibly.
James
1. Home
2. About
3. Find Us
4. Meet Us
5. Welcome to The Greenhouse
6. History
7. Find Us
8. Volunteer
9. Café & Shop
10. Food Information
11. Meet Us
12. Volunteer
Additional comments: I usually click on the main headers to be brought to a page of information containing the content also found in the drop-down list. Although having the drop-down options did make it easier in general.
Robin
1. Home
2. Welcome to the Greenhouse
3. History
4. Find Us
5. Volunteer
Additional comments: Deborah wears glasses so because the text is a light grey colour, it is visually appealing but hard to read. The size is OK though. Easy to navigate from one page to the next using the menu system. Could benefit from some colour to let the website be more visually appealing. All-in-all it was intuitive.
Improvements
Whilst going over the data I have collected from this experiment, I have realised a number of improvements I can make for when I perform a test like this again. know I have
- When writing the content cards, I feel I was too literal and vague. I say literal because I took pieces of content and wrote this on a cue card and I say vague because there was no clear differentiation between whether this was information on a page or a page itself. For example, ‘How to volunteer’ and ‘About volunteering’ were originally construed in my mind as pieces of content on a page named ‘Volunteering’ however some may argue that they are worthy of their own webpages. I could overcome this by creating a colour coding system whereby participants can clearly state whether they think the cue card is referring to content on the page or a page itself.
- A few people commented that when they didn’t know where to put a card, they just placed it under a random header. Solving this could be as simple as having an ‘Other’ section that they have the choice of revisiting later on in the test. Alternatively, if they felt this content does not need to be included in the overall website structure they have the freedom to express this too. I think I was too adamant about asking users to place all of the content cards under a header that they may have felt under pressure to make sure the task was completed rather than voice their opinion.
- Unfortunately, it didn’t occur to me at the time to keep the same basic menu structure for each test. I am very disappointed I didn’t think of this because all the menu structures in my images of the final results are now in random orders. This could also add another aspect to the test where users are asked to sort the headers themselves thus gaining more data about the information hierarchy of the menu structure itself.
- I would like to be able to offer users the chance to display information multiple times. By this, I mean duplicating content throughout the website where necessary. For example, ‘Why to donate’ would be an obvious fit for the ‘Donate’ section of the website, however, this could also be a call to action on the homepage. This could be a case of providing sticky notes for the user to write the additional content on whether sticky note would act as a visual cue that that content has also appeared elsewhere.
- As the only female in my year group, all my testers were male. The user persona I had created was an older woman so there was an obvious clash of personalities. As I was trying to capture the essence of a character from a general demographic of users of The Greenhouse Trust website, I stand by my decision of using Deborah. However, I should have taken more consideration to the fact that the participants may have ever done a user persona test like this before and would find it hard to get into the mind of a fictitious character, let alone one completely unlike themselves. I could have made it more relatable simply by just creating a male character







